Image & Model

You Had to Be There

Classification
Oil on canvas, diptych; digital media
Dimensions
11.8 × 15.7 inches each
Ref.
RC-16
Date
2026

Two paintings of the same candlelit gathering at my middle school, with starkly different compositions.

Watch the projection

Record

The left painting was a direct copy of a photograph. For the one on the right, I described that photograph in prose and used an AI image generator to generate the scene, then I painted it. Both canvases are identical in size, palette, and time commitment.

The goal is to compare how different references shape painting decisions, such as figure placement, candlelight on faces, and the darkness between them.

Then, through this comparison, I examine what happens to contrast, juxtaposition, and invention when an AI-generated reference makes many compositional decisions.

Projection

Oil on canvas (diptych), visual analysis rendered in HTML/CSS, digital projection.

As an extension of You Had to Be There, I projected an LLM's visual analysis directly onto the finished paintings. Grids, numerical values, and confidence scores covered their surfaces, showing how the model attempts to quantify what it sees.

The projection transformed the paintings into objects of machine analysis. Faces, lighting, and compositional relationships became numerical assessments, while the underlying brushwork remained visible.

I wanted to explore the tension between computational interpretation and artistic judgment. The confidence scores suggest certainty, even though the model's interpretation remains incomplete. Having used AI to generate the reference for one painting, I was interested in what happens when the same technology returns to interpret the finished work—and what it might overlook in the process.

A painting of young men in suits holding candles, faces lit from below
Fig. 1 Left: painted from a photograph. Ryan Chen, 2026. Oil on canvas.
A painting of a larger group in suits holding candles in a room with lights above
Fig. 2 Right: painted from an AI-generated image of the same scene. Ryan Chen, 2026. Oil on canvas.
The two paintings hung side by side on a white wall
Fig. 3 You Had to Be There, installation view. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 4 Projection, still 1. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 5 Projection, still 2. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 6 Projection, still 3. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 7 Projection, still 4. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 8 Projection, still 5. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 9 Projection, still 6. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 10 Projection, still 7. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 11 Projection, still 8. Ryan Chen, 2026.
A still from the projection video
Fig. 12 Projection, still 9. Ryan Chen, 2026.