Memory & Archive

Defying the Chinese Exclusion Act

Classification
Research paper
Ref.
RC-02
Date
May 2026

Dean Lung and the institutionalization of East Asian studies at Columbia University.

Thesis

“Dean Lung’s 1901 endowment to Columbia was not an act of charity but a much more deliberate, strategic intervention against the ideological foundations of Chinese exclusion.”

Argument

The paper argues that the exclusion laws, from the Page Act through the Exclusion, Scott and Geary Acts, rested less on labor competition than on a judgment that Chinese people were racially and culturally inferior. It reads the statutes and the speeches made for them.

Dean Lung, recorded as a “companion” in Horace Carpentier’s household, stood in a gap those laws did not address. By endowing Chinese studies at an elite university, and not a hospital, a church or a labor fund, he aimed at that premise.

The gift built a lasting department and repealed nothing. Repeal came in 1943, for wartime reasons. The family records found in Taishan show a husband, father and patriarch whom the American record reduced to “his Chinese valet”.

Context

Written for Advanced U.S. History, 20 May 2026. About 4,700 words with 48 footnotes.

A filled-in census sheet
Fig. 1 Twelfth Census of the United States, 1900, Manhattan, sheet with the Carpentier household. National Archives. Public domain.
Handwritten first page of an act of Congress
Fig. 2 Chinese Exclusion Act, enrolled copy, 1882. National Archives. Public domain.
A magnifying glass with a silver handle
Fig. 3 Silver-handled magnifying glass, Italy, late 19th century. A collection object. Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum, 1957-100-14. CC0.
A gold coin
Fig. 4 United States twenty-dollar gold piece, designed 1905–7, struck 1911. A collection object. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1979.486.8. Public domain.
An engraved steel letter opener
Fig. 5 Engraved steel letter opener, 19th century. A collection object. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 64.101.1599. Public domain.
A newspaper column
Fig. 6 “Carpentier Leaves Columbia a Million,” New York Times, Feb 21, 1918, p. 11. The New York Times.
Portrait of an older man
Fig. 7 Horace W. Carpentier. Public domain.

Sources

  • Chinese Exclusion Act, 22 Stat. 58 (1882)
  • Page Act, 18 Stat. 477 (1875)
  • Twelfth Census of the United States, 1900
  • Chung Sai Yat Po, 21 Aug 1901
  • New York Times, 21 Feb 1918
  • 马万昌家谱 (Ma Wanchang family register), private collection
  • Huang Xiangguang, 白沙侨刊, 2020
  • Hsu, China Review 4:1 (2004)
  • Wang, New York History 80:3 (1999)
  • Godley, Pacific Affairs 62:3 (1989)
  • de Bary, Columbia Magazine, Spring 2002
  • Luo, Strangers in the Land (2025)